In a personal injury case, a multiplier is a numerical value used to quantify the extent of a claimant’s non-economic losses, often referred to as “pain and suffering” or general damages. These losses encompass elements that are intangible and difficult to assign a specific monetary value, such as emotional distress, loss of enjoyment of life, or physical pain.
The multiplier method uses a scale – typically ranging from 1.5 to 5 – to reflect the severity of these damages, with higher values indicating more severe injuries. This value is then multiplied by the total of the claimant’s economic damages (also known a special damages), such as medical expenses and lost wages, to estimate a reasonable compensation for pain and suffering.
Pain and suffering damages refer to the compensation provided for the physical pain and emotional distress suffered by a claimant due to an injury. These damages are often categorized into two types: physical pain and suffering, and mental pain and suffering.
Physical pain and suffering pertain to the discomfort and pain experienced by the victim as a direct result of the injuries sustained. Examples of physical pain and suffering in personal injury claims include:
Mental pain and suffering encapsulates the psychological impact of the injury, such as:
Pain and suffering damages, being non-economic, do not have a clear monetary value and thus require the use of the multiplier method for calculation in personal injury claims.
Deciding on a multiplier in a personal injury case can often be a complex process due to the subjective nature of the categories of pain and suffering. There is no standard multiplier applicable to all cases, as it largely depends on the specific circumstances and severity of each case. Factors influencing the choice of multiplier may include the duration of recovery, the degree of fault, the impact on lifestyle, or the extent of long-term implications of the injury.
Lawyers may use precedents from previous similar cases as a guide, but the ultimate decision is often a matter of negotiation between the claimant’s and defendant’s sides. Therefore, understanding the multiplier method and its application is crucial for claimants to ensure they receive fair compensation for their pain and suffering. It is often advisable to seek expert legal advice when navigating this aspect of a personal injury case.
A high multiplier in a personal injury case is justified based on several contributing factors. These predominantly revolve around the severity of the injury, the impact of the injury on the individual’s daily life, and the long-term repercussions of the incident.
Remember, a high multiplier provides a greater compensation for pain and suffering, reflecting the increased non-economic damages suffered by the victim. Therefore, it is vital to accurately assess all these factors to ensure fair compensation.
While a high multiplier can yield significant pain and suffering damages, its use can sometimes backfire. This primarily occurs because insurance companies or defense lawyers may view an excessively high multiplier as an attempt to overreach or inflate the damages.
Skepticism from insurance adjusters could lead to increased scrutiny of your medical records and personal life, creating a more contentious negotiation process. Moreover, if your claim cannot substantiate the high multiplier used, it may undermine your credibility and cause the defendant to dispute your entire claim.
Additionally, if your case proceeds to court, a judge or jury may perceive an overly high demand as unreasonable or greedy, which could negatively influence their decision. Hence, while it’s critical to accurately convey the extent of your suffering, it’s equally important to maintain a reasonable and justifiable approach when applying the multiplier method.
Lost wages are a crucial part of the calculation in the multiplier method, but they are not included in the multiplier itself. Lost wages, also referred to as lost earnings, represent the income you couldn’t earn due to your injury and the resulting inability to work. These are considered as part of your “special damages” or “economic damages” – essentially, the quantifiable monetary losses resulting from the injury.
When using the multiplier method to calculate pain and suffering, you first total your economic damages, which include medical bills and lost wages. This sum is then multiplied by a selected number (the multiplier) to estimate the value of non-economic damages, like pain and suffering. So while lost wages do not directly influence the multiplier chosen, they are essential to the overall calculation and can significantly impact the total amount of damages claimed.
In cases where you’ve suffered a severe injury that affects your ability to work long-term or permanently, these future lost earnings can also be quantified and included in your economic damages. Therefore, lost wages both past and future, play a significant role when using the multiplier method in personal injury claims.
Let’s examine a hypothetical scenario to understand how the multiplier method is utilized in personal injury claims.
Consider John, who slipped and fell at a local grocery store due to a spill that wasn’t cleaned up promptly. As a result, John suffered from a broken leg and a concussion. His medical bills totaled $20,000. Due to his injuries, John also had to miss work for 12 weeks, which resulted in lost wages amounting to $6,000. In this case, John’s economic damages (medical bills + lost wages) would amount to $26,000.
Due to the severity of his injury and its impact on his life, let’s assume a multiplier of 3 is decided upon (taking into account the guidelines mentioned above). Applying this multiplier to John’s economic damages ($26,000 x 3), we get $78,000. This would be the estimated value for his non-economic damages, including pain and suffering. Therefore, John’s overall claim, combining economic and non-economic damages, would total $104,000 ($26,000 economic damages + $78,000 non-economic damages).
The Multiplier Method is frequently used to estimate a pain and suffering settlement due to its simplicity and relative fairness. It systematically takes into account the tangible economic damages and multiplies them by a certain number (often determined by the severity and impact of injuries) to account for the less tangible, non-economic damages.
This method provides a straightforward way to quantify the subjective and often intangible aspects of pain and suffering, offering a starting point for negotiations. However, it is important to remember that while it provides a guideline, the actual award for pain and suffering can vary greatly based on the specifics of the case, legal jurisdiction, and the decision of the judge or jury.
Despite its widespread use, the Multiplier Method is not without its critics. Here are some common criticisms:
In conclusion, the multiplier method offers a practical, albeit imperfect, approach to estimating general damages for pain and suffering in personal injury claims. It provides a means to translate the intangible and subjective experience of pain and suffering into a monetary sum, taking into account the tangible economic damages incurred.
While its simplicity and relative fairness make it a commonly used method, critics argue that it oversimplifies the process and may result in inconsistency, overemphasis on economic damages, and potential for abuse. Still, despite its drawbacks, the multiplier method remains a critical tool in the initial stages of negotiating personal injury settlements. It is crucial for both plaintiffs and defendants to comprehend its workings, strengths, and limitations to ensure fair representation and outcomes in these cases.
If you need help with a personal injury claim, contact Thompson Law today for a FREE CONSULTATION. We have a long history of obtaining excellent results for our clients, and are standing by ready to guide you through the personal injury claims process.
Thompson Law receives an attorney fee and you pay no legal fees as our client unless we pay you. Thompson Law has 350 years of combined experience in legal representation and has won over $1.8 billion dollars in cash settlements for our clients. We master the art of managing client cases with empathy, compassion, respect and, of course, prodigious skill. Contact us today for a free, risk-free consultation to discuss your accident and your options.
State law limits the time you have to file a claim after an auto accident. If you have been injured in an accident, call now to get the help you need.